Skip to content
Products search
Log In
0
$
0.00
0 lbs
Shop
Holiday Catalog
Cheese
Award Winning Cheese
Our Famous Cheddars
Cheese Curds
String Cheese
Cheese Spreads
Monterey Jack
Baked Cheese
Brick Cheese
Dessert Cheese
Italian Style Cheese
Novelty Cheddar
Reduced Fat Cheese
Specialty Cheese
Swiss Cheese
Gift Boxes & Cards
Gift Boxes
Gift Cards
Corporate Gifts
Jars and Fillings
Gourmet Soups
Gourmet Honeys
Sauces, Salsa, BBQ & Condiments
Jams, Jellies & Preserves
Mustards
Pickled Items
Pie Fillings and Cherries
Renard’s Favorites
Syrups & Mixes
Sweets and Snacks
Crackers
Dips
Gourmet Dog Treats
Homemade Fudge
Homemade Granola
Popcorn
Pretzels
Sausage
Spreads
Sweet Treats
Cocktail Mixes & Coffee
Door County Coffee
Cocktail Mixes
Balsamics and Oils
Cloverleaf Balsamics
Cloverleaf Olive Oils
Cheese Accessories
Door County Specialty Items
Cheese
Gift Boxes
Visit Us
Sturgeon Bay Store
Melt Bistro
Algoma Store (CLOSED)
Bus Group Info
Where to Buy Our Products
Chicago Area
Door County Area
Fox Valley Area
Green Bay Area
Madison area
Manitowoc Sheboygan Area
Milwaukee Area
Oconto Area
Where to Buy Our Fresh Cheese Curds
About Us
About Us
Get to Know Us
In the Press
Our Mission & Value Statements
FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions
Shipping
Corporate Gifts
Fundraising
Donation Requests
Wholesale
Blog
Careers
Cheddar Cheese
Shop our creamy, mouth-watering, award winning Cheddar cheeses!
1 Year Cheddar Cheese
$
5.49
–
$
19.99
View product
10 Year Cheddar Cheese
$
14.49
–
$
27.99
View product
2 Year Cheddar Cheese
Rated
5.00
out of 5
$
5.99
–
$
20.99
View product
2 Year White Cheddar Cheese
Rated
5.00
out of 5
$
6.99
–
$
26.99
View product
3 Year Cheddar Cheese
$
6.49
–
$
12.49
View product
4 Year Cheddar Cheese
Rated
5.00
out of 5
$
8.99
–
$
16.99
View product
5 Year Cheddar Cheese
$
8.49
–
$
15.99
View product
5 Year White Cheddar Cheese
$
6.49
–
$
12.99
View product
9 Year White Cheddar Cheese
$
11.99
–
$
23.49
View product
Aged Sharp Cheddar Cheese Gem
$
40.49
View product
Apple Cinnamon Cheddar Cheese
$
6.49
–
$
11.99
View product
Bacon and Onion Cheddar Cheese
$
7.49
–
$
14.49
View product
Balsamic Caramelized Onion Cheddar Cheese
$
6.99
–
$
12.99
View product
Blue Cheddar Cheese
Rated
4.00
out of 5
$
7.49
–
$
13.99
View product
Caraway Cheddar Cheese
$
5.99
–
$
11.49
View product
Cheddar Cheese – 15 Year
$
18.99
–
$
36.99
View product
Cheddar Cheese – 7 Year
$
9.99
–
$
18.99
View product
Cherry Cheddar Cheese
$
6.49
–
$
11.99
View product
Cherry Chipotle Cheddar Cheese
$
6.49
–
$
11.99
View product
Chili Lime Cheddar Cheese
$
5.99
–
$
11.49
View product
1
2
3
→
Shop
Holiday Catalog
Cheese
Award Winning Cheese
Our Famous Cheddars
Cheese Curds
String Cheese
Cheese Spreads
Monterey Jack
Baked Cheese
Brick Cheese
Dessert Cheese
Italian Style Cheese
Novelty Cheddar
Reduced Fat Cheese
Specialty Cheese
Swiss Cheese
Gift Boxes & Cards
Gift Boxes
Gift Cards
Corporate Gifts
Jars and Fillings
Gourmet Soups
Gourmet Honeys
Sauces, Salsa, BBQ & Condiments
Jams, Jellies & Preserves
Mustards
Pickled Items
Pie Fillings and Cherries
Renard’s Favorites
Syrups & Mixes
Sweets and Snacks
Crackers
Dips
Gourmet Dog Treats
Homemade Fudge
Homemade Granola
Popcorn
Pretzels
Sausage
Spreads
Sweet Treats
Cocktail Mixes & Coffee
Door County Coffee
Cocktail Mixes
Balsamics and Oils
Cloverleaf Balsamics
Cloverleaf Olive Oils
Cheese Accessories
Door County Specialty Items
Cheese
Gift Boxes
Visit Us
Sturgeon Bay Store
Melt Bistro
Algoma Store (CLOSED)
Bus Group Info
Where to Buy Our Products
Chicago Area
Door County Area
Fox Valley Area
Green Bay Area
Madison area
Manitowoc Sheboygan Area
Milwaukee Area
Oconto Area
Where to Buy Our Fresh Cheese Curds
About Us
About Us
Get to Know Us
In the Press
Our Mission & Value Statements
FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions
Shipping
Corporate Gifts
Fundraising
Donation Requests
Wholesale
Blog
Careers