• 

  -%

  10 Year Aged Cheddar Cheese

  From $14.49

  Add to Cart Quickshop Our 15-year Cheddar is the oldest cheese that we sell. If you...
• 

  -%

  Chili Lime Cheddar Cheese

  From $5.99

  Add to Cart Quickshop Our Chili Lime Cheddar will captivate your senses! It starts with the...
• 

  -%

  Sharp White Cheddar RW

  Regular price $9.99

  Add to Cart Quickshop Our 1-Year Cheddar offers a slightly sharp flavor and will surely be...
• 

  -%

  Simon Says Cherry White Cheddar Cheese

  Regular price $8.99

  Add to Cart Quickshop Simon Says Cherry White Cheddar brings two Door County favorites together –...
• 

  -%

  Shredded Cheddar Cheese

  Regular price $8.99

  Add to Cart Quickshop Our classic Cheddar, shredded for your convenience. Try it in tacos, casseroles,...
• 

  -%

  New World Cheddar Cheese

  From $7.49

  Add to Cart Quickshop In 2020, our Master Cheesemaker created a new variety of cheddar with...
• 

  -%

  Gem Cheddar Cheese Wheel

  Regular price $38.99

  Add to Cart Quickshop A three pound waxed wheel gem of Renard’s famous mild to medium...
• 

  -%

  Door County Untouchable Cheddar Cheese

  Regular price $8.99

  Add to Cart Quickshop Untouchable Cheddar is one of our delectable wine-infused cheeses. Our 2-year White...
• 

  -%

  15 Year Aged Cheddar Cheese

  From $18.99

  Add to Cart Quickshop Our 15-year Cheddar is the oldest cheese that we sell. If you...
• 

  -%

  Blue Cheddar Cheese

  From $7.49

  Add to Cart Quickshop The tang of cheddar meets the earthiness of blue cheese with our...
• 

  -%

  5 Year White Cheddar Cheese

  From $6.49

  Add to Cart Quickshop Our 5-year-old Sharp White Cheddar is divine! Aged to perfection, it’s bold,...